Best Insurance for Fix-and-Flip Properties in Florida

Fix-and-flip insurance in Florida is a must-have due to the state’s high natural disaster risks, skyrocketing premiums, and unique challenges for vacant or under-renovation properties.

Here’s what you need to know:

• OfferMarket: A marketplace connecting investors with specialized underwriters. Offers tailored coverage like builder’s risk, vacant property endorsements, and tools/equipment protection. Known for competitive rates and quick quotes.
• Citizens Property Insurance: Florida’s state-backed insurer of last resort. Provides sinkhole and catastrophic ground cover collapse coverage but often comes with higher premiums.
• Farmers Insurance: Offers vacant home insurance, general liability, and worker’s compensation. Flexible 12-month terms and pro-rated refunds for early cancellations.

Florida Insurance Dilemma for Fix & Flip Projects

1. Provider A

OfferMarket offers a tailored solution for Florida fix-and-flip investors, connecting them with underwriters who understand the intricacies of the local market. Unlike a traditional insurance company, OfferMarket acts as a marketplace, simplifying the process of securing renovation insurance that addresses Florida’s unique challenges.

Coverage Options

OfferMarket links investors to coverage packages designed specifically for fix-and-flip properties. Here’s a breakdown of what they offer:

• Property coverage: Protects the structure and materials from risks like fire, theft, vandalism, wind, hail, and water damage.
• General liability coverage: Covers third-party claims, such as slip-and-fall accidents, contractor injuries, or damage to neighboring properties during renovations.
• Builder’s risk coverage: Ensures protection while renovations are underway, covering the structure, materials in transit or on-site, and newly installed features.
• Vacant property endorsement: Keeps your policy active even when the property is unoccupied during renovations, addressing a common gap in standard policies.

Additional options include tools and equipment coverage for safeguarding construction tools and rented equipment, ordinance or law coverage for costs tied to updating older properties to meet current codes, and loss of rents coverage to compensate for lost rental income if a covered event delays occupancy.

Affordability (Premiums and Deductibles)

One of OfferMarket’s standout features is its ability to combat Florida’s notoriously high insurance premiums. Many investors in the state face quotes up to 33% higher than necessary due to a lack of specialized expertise in commercial real estate insurance. OfferMarket bridges this gap by connecting investors with knowledgeable underwriters, helping to secure more competitive rates. This is particularly important as fix-and-flip insurance costs in Florida have risen by over 25% in the past 18 months.

Deductibles vary depending on the underwriter and coverage type. In Florida, hurricane deductibles are often calculated as a percentage of the total coverage rather than a flat fee [1]. OfferMarket’s platform allows investors to compare deductible options, helping them strike the right balance between premium costs and out-of-pocket expenses.

Claims Process Efficiency

OfferMarket prioritizes speed and simplicity when it comes to claims. Their network delivers fast insurance quotes – sometimes within 24 hours – and ensures quick generation of certificates of insurance (COIs) for closing day. They also provide secure record-keeping for all investment policies. This streamlined process is especially critical given Florida’s tight timelines for filing claims [2].

Florida-Specific Risk Coverage

Florida’s fix-and-flip market comes with unique risks, and OfferMarket’s network is designed to address them. Their underwriters understand the challenges of vacant properties and construction-related exposures, offering tailored liability protection. This ensures investors receive guidance from professionals who are well-versed in Florida’s specific insurance needs.

2. Provider B

Citizens Property Insurance Corporation serves as Florida’s state-backed insurer of last resort, offering policies tailored to meet the needs of fix-and-flip projects. Their range of policies – Homeowners (HO-3), Modified Homeowners (HO-8), and Dwelling Property (DP-1 and DP-3) – can be adjusted to provide the necessary building coverage during renovation phases [3].

One standout feature is that Citizens automatically includes Sinkhole Loss coverage with certain policies, while offering it as an optional endorsement for others. Since 2006, they’ve handled over 15,000 sinkhole-related claims, showcasing their experience in this area [3]. Additionally, most policies include Catastrophic Ground Cover Collapse coverage, which applies when geological activity causes an abrupt collapse, visible ground depression, structural damage, and property condemnation [3]. For fix-and-flip investors, these policies address key risks like fire damage, theft of materials, and the increased exposure of vacant properties during renovations.

Affordability (Premiums and Deductibles)

Citizens is required to provide coverage when private insurers decline, but this protection often comes at a higher cost. On average, Florida homeowners pay about $4,218 annually for home insurance – well above the national average of $2,777 [4]. For fix-and-flip properties, premiums typically range from $1,200 to $3,700 per year, depending on the property’s value and the scope of renovations. For instance, a property valued at $150,000 with a $50,000 renovation budget might see premiums between $1,200 and $2,200 annually. On the other hand, higher-value properties with extensive renovations can hit the upper end of the range, around $3,700 per year.

Claims Process Efficiency

The efficiency of the claims process is a critical factor, especially for investors working on tight project timelines. As a state-backed insurer, Citizens has developed a streamlined claims system that handles Florida’s unique risks. Their experience in managing over 15,000 sinkhole-related claims since 2006 highlights their ability to handle complex geological assessments [3]. For specialized coverages like Catastrophic Ground Cover Collapse, claims must include specific documentation proving abrupt collapse, visible ground depression, structural damage, and official property condemnation [3]. This expertise ensures that claims are processed thoroughly and efficiently, which is crucial for investors managing renovation schedules.

Florida-Specific Risk Coverage

Citizens also addresses Florida’s unique environmental challenges by offering additional risk protections. While standard policies exclude flood damage, separate flood insurance is essential – usually obtained through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or private providers. With approximately 2.3 million Florida properties at high risk of flooding over the next 30 years [4], securing flood coverage is a key part of managing risk. The NFIP typically provides up to $250,000 for structural coverage and $100,000 for contents [5]. Citizens’ sinkhole coverage is particularly valuable in areas prone to geological activity, offering options for both Sinkhole Loss and Catastrophic Ground Cover Collapse to ensure protection against various ground-related damages [3]. Additionally, wind damage protection is included, along with mitigation options to help address the state’s hurricane risks.

3. Provider C

Farmers Insurance offers specialized coverage for fix-and-flip investors in Florida, including vacant home insurance, general liability, and worker’s compensation policies. Their offerings are tailored to meet the specific challenges that arise during property renovations.

Coverage Options

Farmers Insurance provides vacant home insurance designed for properties under renovation – a crucial safeguard since standard homeowners policies often exclude unoccupied homes. This coverage protects against risks like vandalism, break-ins, graffiti, and other intentional damages. Their general liability policies help investors manage claims related to bodily injury or property damage that might occur during renovations, covering legal fees and settlements. Additionally, they offer worker’s compensation insurance to cover medical expenses, lost wages, and death benefits for employees. Policies are issued on flexible 12-month terms, allowing adjustments as projects progress [6]. This comprehensive approach ensures coverage aligns with the unique demands of renovation projects.

Affordability (Premiums and Deductibles)

Fix-and-flip insurance premiums in Florida have risen by over 25% in the last 18 months. Farmers Insurance determines premiums based on factors such as property location, value, renovation scope, project timeline, and selected coverage limits. Estimated annual premiums include:

• $1,200 to $2,200 for a $150,000 property with a $50,000 renovation budget
• $1,700 to $2,700 for a $300,000 property with a $100,000 renovation budget
• $2,200 to $3,700 for a $500,000 property with a $200,000 renovation budget

Pro-rated refunds are available for early policy cancellations if projects finish ahead of schedule. Additionally, bundling multiple properties under a single portfolio policy can reduce per-property costs.

Claims Process Efficiency

Farmers Insurance emphasizes a streamlined claims process to minimize disruptions to renovation timelines. Their general liability coverage efficiently handles legal fees and settlements, helping investors avoid delays that could affect project profitability. Worker’s compensation policies ensure that workplace injuries are addressed promptly, covering medical care, lost wages, and survivor benefits. For vacant home insurance, the claims system is designed to respond quickly to issues like vandalism, reducing potential project setbacks [6].

Florida‑Specific Risk Coverage

Farmers Insurance incorporates coverage tailored to Florida’s unique risks and regulatory requirements. By state law, insurance providers must offer sinkhole coverage [9][10], though this may be declined for properties in high-risk sinkhole areas [9][6]. Policies in Florida also automatically include catastrophic ground cover collapse coverage. This applies in cases of sudden ground collapse accompanied by visible depressions, structural damage (including foundation issues), and government-mandated property condemnation [4][6]. These measures address the heightened risks associated with Florida’s environment and regulatory landscape.

With great insights come great
investments. And even greater profit.

We’re here to help you make informed and confident investments.

Schedule a call

Comparison of Insurance Providers

Here’s a breakdown of key insurance providers to help you find the right coverage for your Florida fix-and-flip project.

Coverage Breadth and Specialization

Each provider brings something different to the table in terms of coverage and focus:

• OfferMarket acts as a hub, connecting investors with underwriters who specialize in renovation insurance. They offer property coverage, general liability, builder’s risk, and vacant property endorsements tailored for fix-and-flip projects.
• Citizens Property Insurance Corporation is Florida’s state-backed insurer of last resort. They provide HO-3, HO-8, DP-1, and DP-3 policies, which include automatic sinkhole loss coverage and protection against catastrophic ground cover collapse.
• Farmers Insurance offers policies like vacant home insurance, general liability, and worker’s compensation. Their 12-month terms are flexible and designed to accommodate renovation projects.
  

  Provider

Key Coverage TypesSpecialization

OfferMarketProperty, General Liability, Builder’s Risk, Vacant Property EndorsementMarketplace connecting investors with specialized underwritersCitizens Property InsuranceHO-3, HO-8, DP-1, DP-3 PoliciesState-backed insurer of last resortFarmers InsuranceVacant Home, General Liability, Worker’s CompensationAgent-supported, personalized service

Now, let’s dive into how these providers compare in terms of premiums and claims handling.

Premium Competitiveness and Cost Factors

Fix-and-flip insurance premiums have risen sharply – by over 25% in the last 18 months. On top of that, inefficient quoting processes can drive premiums up by as much as 33%. This makes it crucial to choose a provider that balances competitive pricing with efficient service.

Claims Processing and Service Efficiency

In Florida, insurers are required to meet specific timelines when handling claims. They must investigate claims within 7 days, inspect properties within 30 days, and resolve claims within 60 days after receiving all necessary documentation [11].

Advantages and Disadvantages by Provider

Here’s a closer look at the strengths and weaknesses of each provider:

• OfferMarket: Their marketplace model connects you with experienced underwriters, often securing competitive rates and quotes in as little as 24 hours.
• Citizens Property Insurance Corporation: As a safety net when private insurers won’t provide coverage, Citizens has handled over 15,000 sinkhole-related claims since 2006. However, their premiums are often higher than private options.
• Farmers Insurance: With an agent-supported approach, Farmers offers personalized service and local expertise. They also provide pro-rated refunds if your project wraps up early.

Florida-Specific Considerations

Each provider includes essential coverages tailored to Florida’s unique risks, such as sinkhole protection and catastrophic ground cover collapse coverage. These are crucial given the state’s geological and environmental challenges.

Ultimately, your choice will depend on the complexity of your project, your level of experience as an investor, and whether you prefer a digital-first service like OfferMarket or the more traditional, guaranteed coverage offered by Citizens. For those seeking a personal touch and local expertise, Farmers might be the best fit.

Conclusion

Choosing the right insurance is crucial for protecting your investments and maintaining profitability, especially in Florida’s tough insurance market with its rising premiums. Unfortunately, many investors in the state end up with overly high quotes because their agencies lack expertise in commercial real estate.

As Warren Buffett famously said, “The first rule in investment is don’t lose and the second rule in investment is don’t forget the first rule”. This wisdom applies directly to fix-and-flip insurance, where having the right coverage can make or break your project. It’s a fine line between a successful flip and a costly mistake, and understanding your options is key.

From our research, OfferMarket stands out as the best choice for most Florida fix-and-flip investors. Their marketplace model connects you with underwriters who specialize in renovation projects. They offer fast quotes – sometimes within 24 hours – and work with over 40 carriers to find competitive rates. For investors managing multiple properties, their ability to scale from single homes to larger portfolios is a significant advantage. On the other hand, Farmers Insurance provides a more hands-on, agent-supported experience, making them a great fit for first-time flippers who need extra guidance. Both companies address Florida-specific risks, such as sinkhole coverage and catastrophic ground collapse protection.

When selecting a policy, consider factors like the complexity of your project, the scope of renovations, and your timeline. A comprehensive policy should cover property risks like wind, water, and theft, as well as general liability and business interruption – especially if you plan to rent the property after renovations.

Ultimately, the best approach is to work with a provider that understands Florida’s unique challenges and has access to multiple carriers. The goal isn’t just to find the lowest premium but to secure reliable coverage that keeps your investment strategy on track, even when unexpected issues arise. With the right insurance partner, you can focus on flipping properties, not worrying about financial setbacks.